Key Takeaways
- Public opposition to AI‑related infrastructure is rising sharply, with a majority of Americans now resisting data‑center projects in their communities.
- Senator Bernie Sanders’ call for the public to own half of AI value highlights a growing debate over how to share the technology’s economic gains.
- Scholars such as Jaron Lanier and Raul Castro Fernandez advocate “data dignity” models that would compensate individuals for the data that train AI systems.
- Valuing each person’s data contribution remains fraught with subjectivity and cost, prompting calls for collective‑management approaches akin to music royalties.
- Proposals for new legal rights and AI‑focused unions aim to give people collective bargaining power over how AI is developed and governed.
- Existing policy tools—higher corporate taxes, stronger antitrust enforcement, and a reduced workweek—are presented as more immediate, proven avenues to redistribute AI wealth.
- Policymakers warn against repeating past mistakes with social media and outsourcing, urging proactive, democratic oversight of AI’s societal impact.
Public Opposition to AI Infrastructure Grows
Recent polling shows a swift turn in American sentiment toward AI‑related construction. An Emerson College survey released this week found that only 27 % of respondents support building data centers in or near their communities, while 63 % oppose them—a stark shift from a December 2025 poll where 33 % expressed support and 42 % opposed. Residents like Will Hollingsworth of Northeast Ohio voiced their frustration at a public comment session, saying, “I see a gamble where the big tech companies get the gold while Portage County foots the bill.” He added, “We’re being asked to sacrifice the lifeblood of our city so that a trillion‑dollar company can save a fraction of a cent on its margins.” Such comments, which went viral, illustrate a growing perception that AI benefits accrue to distant corporations while local communities bear environmental and fiscal costs.
Bernie Sanders’ Half‑Ownership Proposal and the Policy Debate
Senator Bernie Sanders recently suggested that the public should own half of artificial intelligence, a notion unlikely to become law soon but emblematic of a broader conversation among economists, technologists, and policymakers. The central question is how Americans can capture a share of the trillions of dollars in new economic value that AI is projected to generate. While many ideas remain untested, the urgency has intensified as AI‑related wealth has already concentrated in stock markets, leaving large segments of the population with limited direct gains. Survey work indicates that a majority of U.S. workers now favor holding corporations more accountable, with concepts like an AI sovereign wealth fund gaining traction. Even before its anticipated IPO, OpenAI has reportedly discussed offering the government a 5 % equity stake, signaling that some in the industry recognize the need for public participation.
Data Dignity: Compensating Individuals for Their Contributions
Among the most discussed solutions is the idea of “data dignity,” championed by computer scientist Jaron Lanier, who currently serves as the Office of the Chief Technical Officer Prime Unifying Scientist at Microsoft Research. Lanier argues that people should receive compensation for the information and contributions that help create AI systems. He recalls his interaction with Senator Sanders at Stanford, noting, “Whether [his proposal] would be a good idea depends on the nature of the government that would be responsible for routing benefits to people.” Lanier warns that if the government simply becomes “just another AI company,” the better path is a more “distributed economic model” where good data and supervision translate into real money for contributors. He adds, “If the future is to be the normative Silicon Valley one, where people will be fictionally treated as becoming useless because their contributions have been anonymized and dismissed in favor of pretending AI did all the work, then it is better for some kind of support to come through a government structure with a participatory/democratic element.”
Practical Challenges of Valuing Individual Data
Turning the data‑dignity vision into reality faces significant hurdles. AI models are trained on vast corpora drawn from millions or billions of sources, making it difficult to isolate the value of any single individual’s contribution. Raul Castro Fernandez, an assistant professor of computer science at the University of Chicago, pushes back against the claim that such compensation is infeasible. He contends, “The strongest version of profit sharing is not a tax but a compensation system tied to the human contributions that make AI systems valuable in the first place.” Fernandez proposes a collective‑management system reminiscent of music royalties: AI firms would pay a share of model profits into a pool, with the pool’s size anchored by evidence of how much model performance depends on data, and payments distributed according to audited measures of data contribution. Conversely, Nicholas Vincent and Brent Hecht caution that assigning precise valuations to each datum is subjective and potentially counterproductive. Their 2023 study warns, “Seemingly minor design choices can seriously change the distribution of data values… If a technology is reliant on the collective contributions of millions or billions of people, we already know each individual value will be very small, so why bother spending time and energy performing [potentially costly] data value estimation?”
Collective Rights: New Unions and Governance Models for AI
Recognizing the limits of individual payouts, some experts advocate for new legal frameworks that give people collective power over AI. Matt Prewitt, president of the RadicalxChange Foundation, proposes creating a class of inalienable rights akin to 21st‑century unions, where individuals cannot waive these rights alone but must join associations to exercise them. Such associations would enjoy “a very serious seat at the table with AI companies, and that have the power to gain shares, remuneration, governance, and power.” Glen Weyl, a principle researcher at Microsoft and RadicalxChange founder, argues that simply dividing or consolidating ownership is insufficient. He warns that fractionalizing ownership “just ‘spreads around’ the same old extractive incentives of conventional ownership,” while consolidating it “puts all the eggs in one basket,” heightening risks of institutional capture and illegitimate representation. Instead, Weyl and his colleagues promote models centered on common ownership that embed democratic participation directly into AI governance.
Existing Policy Tools: Taxes, Antitrust, and Shorter Workweeks
Other commentators maintain that proven policy levers can already address AI‑driven inequality without resorting to untested schemes. Economist Dean Baker, co‑founder of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, points to stronger corporate taxes, robust antitrust enforcement, and labor protections as viable routes. Baker suggests requiring firms to turn over non‑voting shares equal to a targeted tax rate—for example, 25 % of shares for a 25 % tax rate—thereby linking profit sharing directly to fiscal policy. He also notes that rigorous antitrust action could prevent a handful of tech giants from monopolizing AI profits, drawing a parallel to how cheap Chinese imports once harmed blue‑collar workers: “We let in Chinese manufactured goods to screw large segments of the blue‑collar workforce. We should not have protectionism to keep Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg ridiculously rich.” Beyond taxation and competition policy, Baker advocates reducing the standard workweek as a means to share AI‑generated productivity gains. He observes, “We set the 40‑hour work week 90 years ago and it has not changed since. Other countries have shortened the work week, work year. If AI is going to give us the promised boom in productivity, let’s lower the threshold to 32 hours, or possibly even lower. We can also double the overtime premium to 100 % rather than 50 %.” Such measures, he argues, are administratively straightforward and have international precedent.
Learning from Past Tech Policy Mistakes and Looking Ahead
Senior policymakers are keen to avoid repeating the regulatory lapses that accompanied the rise of social media and the earlier wave of global outsourcing. They view AI—and especially its impact on employment—as a looming electoral and social issue that demands proactive, democratic oversight. While concepts like a universal basic income (or Elon Musk’s “universal high income”) have circulated for years, Baker suggests a simpler labor‑market mechanism: reducing work hours to distribute efficiency gains more broadly. The consensus among experts is that any solution must balance innovation with equity, ensuring that the public—not just a few corporations—reaps the benefits of AI’s transformative potential. As the debate continues, the challenge will be to design institutions that are both resilient to capture and responsive to the evolving realities of machine‑learning‑driven economies.
https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/26/how-can-ai-wealth-be-shared-with-all-americans.html

