Key Takeaways
- Ukraine’s former commander‑in‑chief and current UK ambassador, Valery Zaluzhny, stated unequivocally that Ukraine will never join NATO.
- He argues that NATO’s doctrinal framework remains rooted in Second World War‑era thinking, making it incompatible with the modern Ukrainian Armed Forces.
- Despite his skepticism about NATO, Zaluzhny enjoys high domestic trust, with 73 % support in a recent Kyiv International Institute of Sociology survey.
- He sees alternative security arrangements—such as a prospective European security bloc or deeper ties with the UK‑led Joint Expeditionary Force (JEF)—as more realistic guarantees for Ukraine.
- Ukraine recently obtained “enhanced partner” status in the JEF, gaining access to intelligence sharing, joint exercises, and regional defense planning without a mutual‑defense obligation.
- Parallel to NATO discussions, Ukraine continues EU accession talks, having opened two negotiation clusters, but progress is hampered by Hungarian vetoes and slow domestic reforms.
- A recent Russian drone, bomb, and artillery strike in the Dnipropetrovsk region underscores the urgent security challenges Ukraine faces while pursuing these diplomatic paths.
Context and Setting
Valery Zaluzhny, Ukraine’s former commander‑in‑chief who now serves as the country’s ambassador to the United Kingdom, delivered his remarks during a Euro‑Atlantic integration discussion at a general gathering of ambassadors in Kyiv. The comments were reported by European Pravda and came amid broader conversations about Ukraine’s security outlook and its relationships with Western alliances.
Dismissal of NATO Membership
When asked about Ukraine’s participation in the UK‑led Joint Expeditionary Force (JEF), Zaluzhny pivoted directly to the NATO question. He declared, “I know NATO very well. For roughly 12 years I’ve personally worked on mastering NATO standards, and every year I’ve listened to the same fairy tale that we’re about to join. Unfortunately, we never will.” His statement was a blunt rejection of the prospect of future NATO membership, despite years of Ukrainian efforts to align with alliance standards.
Public Trust and Popularity
The timing of Zaluzhny’s comments is notable given his standing among Ukrainians. A survey conducted by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology (KIIS) between May 7 and June 3 found that he remains the country’s most trusted public figure, garnering 73 % support. This high level of confidence adds weight to his strategic assessments, even as they diverge from the official government line on NATO aspirations.
Doctrinal Mismatch as Core Obstacle
Zaluzhny identified a fundamental incompatibility between the Ukrainian Armed Forces and NATO’s current doctrine. He argued that Ukraine’s military has evolved to a level that cannot be folded into an alliance still operating on “doctrines of the Second World War.” In his view, NATO’s institutional inertia prevents it from adapting quickly enough to accommodate a modern, high‑intensity force like Ukraine’s.
Capability Gaps and Technological and Comparative Strength
Beyond doctrine, Zaluzhny highlighted practical capability gaps. He noted that even if Ukraine closed the gap with NATO members’ standards, it would still possess only about half the strength of Russia’s military forces. Consequently, Ukraine requires advanced technologies that are presently available only in NATO countries—particularly anti‑ballistic missile systems and enhanced space‑based capabilities—to bridge that deficit.
Exploring Alternative Security Guarantees
Rather than pinning hopes on NATO, Zaluzhny pointed to emerging frameworks that could offer more realistic security guarantees. He floated the idea of a probable “European security bloc” as a viable alternative. Simultaneously, he praised Ukraine’s growing role in the JEF coalition, describing it as a promising avenue for deeper integration into Europe’s security architecture, even though he characterized the JEF’s governing structures as “weak” and not yet fully aligned with Ukrainian needs.
Ukraine’s Enhanced Partner Role in the JEF
As of 5 November 2025, Ukraine achieved a new milestone by becoming the first non‑alliance state to receive “enhanced partner” status within the JEF. The coalition, led by ten Northern European nations (the UK, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Iceland, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway, and Sweden), operates outside NATO structures and focuses on strategically sensitive regions such as the Baltic and North Seas, the Arctic, and the North Atlantic. Ukraine’s enhanced status grants it access to intelligence sharing, joint exercises, and regional defense planning, reflecting its frontline experience in countering hybrid aggression, air‑defense innovation, drone employment, and long‑range strike capabilities.
EU Accession Progress and Obstacles
Zaluzhny’s remarks on NATO coincide with Ukraine’s separate push for European Union membership. Kyiv has opened two of the EU’s six accession negotiation clusters this year—Fundamentals in June and External Relations in July—moving the bid from political rhetoric into concrete technical talks. However, the process faces hurdles: Hungary has twice blocked the screening approval needed to open additional clusters, postponing the next review to September. Moreover, Ukraine’s reform tempo lags behind that of Western Balkan peers such as Montenegro and Albania. A mid‑July government reshuffle, which will see the permanent representative in Brussels, Vsevolod Chentsov, swap roles with Deputy Prime Minister Taras Kachka, has further complicated EU diplomacy.
Regional Security Incident: Dnipropetrovsk Strike
Amid these diplomatic developments, the security situation on the ground remains dire. A recent Russian attack using drones, bombs, and artillery struck four districts of the Dnipropetrovsk region, killing a child and wounding 15 others while damaging civilian infrastructure. The incident underscores the urgent need for robust security guarantees—whether through NATO, alternative blocs, or strengthened partnerships like the JEF—as Ukraine continues to defend its sovereignty.
Overall Implications
Valery Zaluzhny’s candid assessment captures a growing sentiment among Ukrainian security experts: the path to NATO membership appears increasingly doubtful due to doctrinal and temporal mismatches, while alternative mechanisms such as a prospective European security bloc or deeper JEF integration offer more immediate, tangible benefits. His high public trust lends credibility to these views, potentially shaping future policy debates. Simultaneously, Ukraine’s EU accession remains underway but is hampered by external vetoes and internal reform delays. The stark reality of ongoing Russian aggression, highlighted by the Dnipropetrovsk strike, reinforces the imperative for Ukraine to secure reliable, effective security arrangements—whatever form they may ultimately take.

