Key Takeaways
- The Pentagon has launched a “top‑to‑bottom” review of the Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) program to address cost and compliance burdens on small defense contractors.
- Third‑party assessment requirements have been suspended pending the review, but self‑assessments and DoD‑led cybersecurity evaluations remain in force.
- The review team, led by DoD CIO Kirsten Davies, has 60 days to gather feedback and 15 days to submit recommendations, with a target completion date in late September.
- Officials cite a severe shortage of certified CMMC assessors and high compliance costs as primary barriers for small businesses, though industry observers note that assessor capacity and cost‑effective options have improved.
- Any changes to CMMC could be implemented quickly through class deviations or interim rules, allowing the department to adapt without a lengthy rulemaking process.
- Continued reliance on self‑assessments raises potential False Claims Act (FCA) exposure for contractors who misrepresent their compliance status.
- The review will examine whether to retain, modify, or replace the third‑party assessment ecosystem that was created to overcome widespread self‑attestation failures identified in earlier audits.
Pentagon Initiates CMMC Review Amid Small‑Business Concerns
On July 16, Defense Department Chief Information Officer Kirsten Davies announced the first meeting of the CMMC review team following a tour of Kform, a small defense manufacturer in Sterling, Va. Davies was joined by Small Business Administrator Kelly Loeffler and Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment Michael Duffey. The visit underscored the department’s focus on how cybersecurity requirements affect smaller firms that form a vital part of the defense industrial base.
Rationale for the Review: Cost and Compliance Burdens
Davies explained that the decision to suspend CMMC third‑party assessment requirements and launch a comprehensive review stemmed from clear evidence that the planned compliance trajectory was imposing prohibitive costs and unacceptable burdens on contractors. Data from the Small Business Administration and other sources showed that many small firms struggled to meet the financial and operational demands of the existing CMMC framework, threatening their ability to compete for defense contracts.
Structure and Timeline of the Review Process
The review team will collect input through a published request for information and a series of nationwide listening sessions targeting defense contractors—especially small businesses—as well as cybersecurity professionals and assessors. Davies stated that the team has 60 days to gather feedback and analyze the program, followed by 15 days to produce a report with recommendations for herself and Duffey. If the schedule holds, the review will be finalized by late September, after which the findings and recommendations are expected to be made public.
Suspension of Third‑Party Assessment Requirements
As part of the review, the DoD has temporarily halted the rollout of CMMC third‑party assessments that were slated to become standard in many defense contracts beginning November 10. While the suspension is in effect, the department continues to enforce CMMC self‑assessment obligations and retains the ability to evaluate contractor cybersecurity through other mechanisms, such as the Defense Industrial Base Cybersecurity Assessment Center (DIBCAC).
Critique of the Current CMMC Approach
Davies was candid in her criticism of the existing third‑party assessment model, describing it as “burdensome, red‑tape ridden, check‑the‑box, [and] a point‑in‑time view” of how companies handle sensitive data. She emphasized that the review will not pursue change merely for its own sake but will consider options ranging from minor adjustments to a full overhaul, guided by the input of small and innovative firms seeking lower barriers to entry.
Historical Context: From CMMC 1.0 to CMMC 2.0
The CMMC program originated in 2019 under the first Trump administration after inspector general audits revealed widespread false self‑attestations to cybersecurity standards, which had contributed to significant breaches by nation‑state actors. A subsequent Biden‑era review aimed to alleviate small‑business concerns, resulting in the streamlined “CMMC 2.0” framework finalized in 2024. DoD began phasing in the new requirements with self‑assessments, while voluntary third‑party assessments gained traction and some program offices started inserting Level 2 third‑party requirements into solicitations.
Current Enforcement Mechanisms During the Review
Despite the pause on third‑party assessments, DoD still mandates CMMC self‑assessments and requires contractors to protect controlled unclassified information (CUI) in line with National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) controls. The department can also evaluate compliance via DIBCAC, the NSA’s Cybersecurity Directorate, and the DoD Cyber Crime Center (DC3). However, officials acknowledge that these services presently cover only a fraction of the NIST control set, which originally motivated the creation of the CMMC third‑party assessment ecosystem.
Legal Risks Associated with Reliance on Self‑Assessments
Industry experts warn that shifting greater reliance onto self‑assessments increases exposure to False Claims Act liability. As noted by Kate Growley of Crowell & Moring, contractors who self‑report compliance without an accredited third‑party verification risk misrepresenting their cybersecurity posture, potentially triggering FCA penalties if the government later discovers deficiencies. This risk underscores the importance of maintaining credible assurance mechanisms even as the program is reexamined.
Assessor Capacity and Cost Considerations
Pentagon officials point to a shortage of certified CMMC assessors and high compliance costs as key impediments for small businesses. Davies cited a “severe shortage” of third‑party assessors, while Loeffler warned that compliance expenses exceeding $500,000 could push small firms out of the defense base. Conversely, Eric Crusius of Hunton Andrews Kurth argued that much of the perceived cost stems from implementing underlying NIST controls rather than the CMMC certification itself, noting that a Level 2 third‑party assessment averages around $105,000 and that the market now offers more affordable, scalable options. The Cyber AB reports over 1,000 certified assessors, estimating a need for 2,000–3,000 to meet full implementation demand projected for late 2028.
Potential Outcomes and Path Forward
Depending on the review’s findings, DoD could retain the CMMC 2.0 structure with targeted tweaks, eliminate or reduce third‑party requirements, or revert to a greater reliance on self‑assessments supplemented by DoD‑led audits. Officials noted that, if substantial changes are warranted, the department could enact them swiftly using class deviations or interim rules, bypassing the typical lengthy rulemaking cycle. The ultimate aim is to preserve cybersecurity resilience across the defense industrial base while ensuring that compliance demands do not unfairly disadvantage small, innovative contractors.

