Key Takeaways
- The cybersecurity ETF landscape is dominated by two funds: First Trust NASDAQ Cybersecurity ETF (CIBR) and Amplify Cybersecurity ETF (HACK).
- CIBR follows a market‑cap‑weighted index that lets the largest pure‑play vendors dominate, giving it a concentrated bet on platform consolidation.
- HACK uses an adjusted market‑cap approach that flattens weightings and includes defense contractors, reflecting a thesis that cybersecurity is also a national‑security budget line.
- Over the past decade CIBR has outperformed HACK by roughly 90 percentage points, but in 2026 HACK’s YTD return exceeds CIBR’s, showing how leadership shifts can reverse the advantage.
- CIBR’s sizable holdings in megacap tech names (Microsoft, Alphabet, Cisco, Broadcom) create overlap with broad tech ETFs, whereas HACK offers less overlap and more exposure to mid‑cap pure‑plays and defense firms.
- Investors should choose CIBR if they believe large platform vendors will continue to drive cybersecurity spend; HACK suits those who expect broader, equal‑weighted exposure, including defense‑adjacent names, to lead the next phase of growth.
Introduction
Cybersecurity has become one of the fastest‑growing segments of the technology sector, with market forecasts projecting expansion from roughly $454 billion in 2025 to more than $1 trillion by 2031. Retail investors seeking exposure to this trend have two primary exchange‑traded funds to choose from: the First Trust NASDAQ Cybersecurity ETF (CIBR) and the Amplify Cybersecurity ETF (HACK). Although both funds target the same thematic universe, they employ different index methodologies and consequently deliver distinct risk‑return profiles. Understanding these differences is essential for aligning an ETF choice with an investor’s view of how cybersecurity spending will evolve.
CIBR Overview
CIBR tracks the Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index, a market‑cap‑weighted benchmark that applies individual security caps to prevent any single name from dominating excessively. As of March 31 2026, the fund’s five largest holdings—Palo Alto Networks (8.46 %), CrowdStrike (8.25 %), Cisco (7.67 %), Broadcom (7.61 %), and Fortinet (7.40 %)—together account for about 39 % of net assets. This concentration reflects a belief that a handful of large vendors will capture an increasing share of security budgets as organizations consolidate point solutions onto broader platforms. In addition to pure‑play security firms, CIBR includes infrastructure heavyweights such as Microsoft, Alphabet, IBM, and Accenture, which pulls its behavior closer to that of a general enterprise‑software ETF.
HACK Overview
HACK follows the Nasdaq ISE Cyber Security Select Index, which uses an adjusted market‑cap weighting scheme designed to flatten position sizes. Consequently, the top holding—Palo Alto Networks—represents only 6.61 % of the fund, and the ten largest holdings collectively make up 51.86 % of net assets. The fund holds just 23 securities, a markedly smaller roster than CIBR’s 45. Importantly, HACK’s index incorporates defense contractors such as General Dynamics (5.11 %) and Northrop Grumman (4.56 %). This inclusion signals a different investment thesis: cybersecurity is not only a corporate software purchase but also a line item in national‑security budgets, where government spending on cyber‑warfare and critical‑infrastructure protection can drive performance.
Holdings and Weighting Comparison
The contrasting methodologies translate into tangible differences in portfolio construction. CIBR’s market‑cap approach yields a top‑five weight of roughly 39 %, while HACK’s flatter weighting keeps the top‑five share near 28 %. CIBR holds 45 stocks, providing greater diversification across the cybersecurity value chain, whereas HACK’s 23‑stock portfolio is more concentrated but evenly spread. Both funds carry an identical expense ratio of 0.60 %, so cost differences do not explain performance divergence. Net assets also diverge markedly: CIBR manages about $9.49 billion, more than triple HACK’s $2.71 billion asset base, reflecting greater retail adoption of the consolidation‑focused strategy.
Historical Performance Divergence
Over the past ten years, CIBR has delivered a cumulative return of 446.18 %, outpacing HACK’s 355.74 % by approximately 90 percentage points. This gap stems largely from CIBR’s heavier exposure to the mega‑cap pure‑play winners that benefited from the platform‑consolidation trend during much of the 2010s. Looking at a five‑year window, CIBR’s gain of 93.68 % still exceeds HACK’s 75.56 %, though the margin narrows as the market cycle matures. These long‑term results illustrate how a concentration in the largest vendors can amplify returns when those firms lead the sector, but also heighten vulnerability if leadership shifts elsewhere.
Recent 2026 Performance Reversal
In 2026 the performance narrative has flipped. Year‑to‑date, HACK is up 35.44 % compared with CIBR’s 28.62 %, and its one‑month advance of 12.47 % nearly doubles CIBR’s 6.51 % gain. The reversal is driven by two factors: first, rising cyber‑warfare budgets have prompted a rerating of defense contractors such as General Dynamics and Northrop Grumman, which HACK holds at meaningful weights; second, smaller pure‑play names that have languished for years are beginning to attract investor interest, benefiting HACK’s flatter weighting scheme. When leadership broadens beyond the largest platform providers, HACK’s structure captures the upside more effectively; when the mega‑caps resume dominance, CIBR’s concentration works in its favor.
Practical Comparison Summary
A side‑by‑side look at the funds highlights the core distinctions:
- Index: CIBR – Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity (market‑cap weighted); HACK – Nasdaq ISE Cyber Security Select (adjusted market‑cap, flatter).
- Weighting Approach: CIBR applies market caps with individual caps; HACK uses an adjusted market‑cap method that equalizes exposure.
- Number of Holdings: CIBR holds 45 securities; HACK holds 23.
- Top‑Five Concentration: CIBR ≈ 39 %; HACK ≈ 28 %.
- Expense Ratio: Both at 0.60 %.
- Net Assets: CIBR ≈ $9.49 B; HACK ≈ $2.71 B.
- YTD 2026 Return: CIBR 28.62 %; HACK 35.44 %.
- 10‑Year Return: CIBR 446.18 %; HACK 355.74 %.
These metrics encapsulate why the two ETFs can behave differently despite targeting the same thematic space.
Overlap with Broad Tech Exposures
Because CIBR allocates substantial weight to megacap technology names—Microsoft, Alphabet, Cisco, and Broadcom—investors who already hold a broad‑market or large‑cap tech ETF may experience double‑counting of that exposure. This overlap can dilute the pure‑play cybersecurity tilt that many investors seek. In contrast, HACK’s portfolio contains fewer mega‑cap tech stocks and a larger share of mid‑cap pure‑plays and defense firms, resulting in considerably lower overlap with an S&P 500 or total‑stock‑market allocation. As highlighted in Goldman Sachs’ 2026 outlook, which emphasized supply chains, resources, and national defense as portfolio priorities, HACK’s structure aligns more closely with an economic‑security theme that is distinct from generic tech exposure.
The Verdict – Which ETF Fits Your View?
Investors who believe the cybersecurity market will continue to be dominated by a few platform‑consolidation winners—where large vendors bundle security into broader enterprise suites—may find CIBR the better fit. Its ten‑year track record reflects a period when those mega‑caps outperformed the field, and its concentration rewards that scenario. Conversely, those who anticipate a broader rally driven by rising government cyber‑defense budgets, renewed interest in niche pure‑play vendors, or a shift toward equal‑weighted exposure may prefer HACK. Its flatter weighting and defense‑contractor inclusion allow it to capture upside when leadership expands beyond the largest software providers. Ultimately, the choice hinges on whether you expect the next leg of cybersecurity growth to be led by incumbent giants (CIBR) or by a more diversified set of players including defense and mid‑cap innovators (HACK).
Contact Information
For any questions, corrections, or further clarification regarding this analysis, please reach out to [email protected].
This summary has been prepared to provide a concise yet thorough overview of the differences between the First Trust NASDAQ Cybersecurity ETF (CIBR) and the Amplify Cybersecurity ETF (HACK), helping investors decide which fund aligns with their outlook on the evolving cybersecurity landscape.

