Key Takeaways
- Queensland’s proposed bill would require all e‑bike riders to hold a driver’s licence, limit speeds to 10 km/h on shared paths and footpaths, and ban riders under 16.
- Vision Australia supports the speed limit but argues it remains unsafe for blind or low‑vision pedestrians and urges further restrictions such as footpath bans and audible alerts.
- Brisbane City Council, the RACQ, and several regional councils oppose the licence requirement and blanket speed cap, citing disincentives to youth, lack of evidence that e‑bikes are riskier than regular bikes, and potential spill‑over onto roads.
- Personal testimony from e‑bike commuters shows families already travel at safe, child‑appropriate speeds (15‑18 km/h) and view the proposed rules as contradictory and impractical.
- Data from Norway and Australian sensor studies indicate conventional bicycles suffer more injuries than e‑bikes, and typical e‑bike speeds average 18.5 km/h, well above the proposed limit.
- Critics warn that overly strict limits could push riders onto higher‑speed roads, increase traffic congestion, and undermine active‑transport goals.
Overview of Proposed Queensland E‑bike Legislation
The Crisafulli government introduced a bill following an inquiry into injuries linked to high‑speed illegal e‑motorbikes and e‑scooters. The legislation targets legal e‑bike riders, proposing three core changes: mandatory possession of a driver’s licence, a uniform speed limit of 10 km/h on all shared paths and footpaths, and a prohibition on anyone under the age of 16 operating an e‑bike. These measures are presented as safety enhancements, aiming to reduce conflicts between e‑mobility users and pedestrians on mixed‑use infrastructure.
Specific Restrictions: Licensing, Speed Limit, Age Ban
Under the draft law, every e‑bike rider would need to satisfy the same licensing requirements as a motor‑vehicle driver, effectively treating e‑bikes as motorised transport. The 10 km/h cap aligns with a jogging pace and would apply not only to urban shared paths but also to rail trails classified as footpaths. Simultaneously, the bill would bar anyone younger than 16 from riding e‑bikes, a move intended to protect minors from high‑powered machines but which also affects low‑wattage, pedal‑assist models commonly used for school commutes.
Support from Vision Australia and Safety Concerns for Vulnerable Pedestrians
Vision Australia welcomed the 10 km/h limit as an improvement over higher proposed speeds, yet warned that even this velocity poses a significant hazard for pedestrians who are blind or have low vision. The organisation argued that without audible warnings or physical separation, such users cannot reliably detect approaching e‑bikes. Consequently, Vision Australia urged the government to go further—prohibiting e‑bike use on footpaths altogether and mandating sound‑emitting devices similar to those required on electric vehicles.
Opposition from Brisbane City Council
Brisbane City Council chief executive Dr Kerrie Freeman criticised both the licensing mandate and the under‑16 ban. She asserted that requiring a driver’s licence would deter young people from adopting active transport and unfairly exclude individuals with health conditions who cannot obtain a licence yet can safely ride a bicycle or scooter. Freeman highlighted that there is no evidence indicating electrically power‑assisted cycles (EPACs) are more dangerous than conventional bicycles, and she noted the financial burden of installing signage for a blanket speed limit across Brisbane’s extensive shared‑path network.
Concerns Raised by the RACQ
The RACQ argued that compelling e‑bike riders to hold a driver’s licence is unnecessary; instead, they propose a dedicated e‑mobility proficiency test that does not require a “fitness to drive” declaration. Advocacy general manager Josh Cooney warned that a uniform 10 km/h limit could push riders onto higher‑speed road environments or discourage e‑bike use altogether, potentially increasing traffic congestion and undermining the state’s active‑transport objectives. He suggested focusing enforcement on unsafe behaviours—such as close passes with pedestrians—rather than imposing blanket speed restrictions.
Perspectives from Local Riders: Kim Fisher’s Experience
Brisbane resident Kim Fisher, who uses an electric cargo bike as a family “second vehicle,” described how the proposed rules clash with everyday reality. She and her family routinely travel under 5 km for errands, school trips, and recreational rides, often moving at 15‑18 km/h—a speed she considers safe and appropriate for children. Fisher pointed out the apparent inconsistency: if her husband switched to a regular bicycle while maintaining the same route and speed, the activity would be permissible, yet the same behaviour on an e‑bike would be penalised. She found the notion that her family’s rides are “dangerous” perplexing given their cautious riding habits around pedestrians, dogs, and children.
Analysis from Academic and Industry Data
A recent Norwegian study cited in the article found that conventional bicycles accounted for more than twice as many injuries as e‑bikes, challenging the premise that e‑bikes are inherently riskier. Complementing this, sensor‑data firm See.Sense reported that the mean speed of Australian e‑bikes is 18.5 km/h, compared with 22.5 km/h for standard bicycles. These figures suggest that most e‑bike riders already travel at speeds well above the proposed 10 km/h limit, and that the injury profile of e‑bikes does not justify the severity of the restrictions under consideration.
Positions of Other Queensland Councils (Gold Coast, Noosa, Somerset)
The Gold Coast City Council objected to the licence requirement, the age cap, and the 10 km/h speed limit, arguing that the rule would unfairly penalise teenagers who rely on pedal‑assist e‑bikes for school commutes and that compliance would be low, possibly creating unstable riding conditions. Noosa Shire Council’s chief executive Larry Sengstock warned that banning under‑16 riders would increase car dependence in regional areas lacking public transport, while describing the 10 km/h limit as “barely above walking pace” and unviable for longer commutes. Somerset Regional Council noted that about half of users on the Brisbane Valley Rail Trail are e‑bike riders, including families supervising teens, and warned that the restrictions could deter tourism and local recreation.
Implications for Active Transport and Traffic Congestion
Critics collectively contend that the proposed measures could have counterproductive effects. By imposing licensing barriers and low speed caps, the bill may dissuade new users—particularly youth and those without licences—from choosing e‑bikes, leading them to rely more on cars for short trips. Conversely, riders who ignore the limit might migrate to roads shared with higher‑speed traffic, raising the risk of collisions. Both outcomes would likely increase vehicle kilometres travelled and erode the congestion‑reduction benefits that active‑transport policies aim to deliver.
Conclusion and Outlook
The Queensland e‑bike bill reflects a tension between precautionary safety aspirations and the practical realities of how e‑mobility is used across the state. While groups such as Vision Australia emphasise protecting vulnerable pedestrians, numerous councils, industry bodies, and everyday riders argue that the proposed licence requirement, universal 10 km/h limit, and age ban are excessive, not evidence‑based, and could jeopardise the very active‑transport goals the legislation purports to support. As the parliamentary committee reviews the submissions, the final shape of the law will likely hinge on finding a middle ground that addresses genuine safety concerns without undermining the accessibility and appeal of e‑bikes for Queenslanders.

