Police Intervene at Turbulent Royal Australasian College of Physicians Board Meeting

0
54

Key Takeaways

  • The Royal Australasian College of Physicians (RACP) has been embroiled in a months‑long power struggle between incumbent President Professor Jennifer Martin and President‑elect Dr Sharmila Chandran.
  • On Wednesday 22 April 2026, police were called to the college’s board meeting after Chandran allegedly convened an unauthorized session to vote Martin out of office.
  • The board’s official statement asserted that Martin remained the lawful chair, that Chandran “spoke over” her and moved the meeting to a closed room without the president, CEO, other directors, or the interim company secretary present.
  • Chandran claimed a 54.5 % vote in favor of ousting Martin, declared herself the new board chair, and said she had already notified the Australian Charities and Not‑for‑profits Commission (ACNC) of the change.
  • Police attended the scene but concluded no criminal offence had occurred; they spoke with several attendees and found no grounds for charges.
  • The controversy raises serious governance questions about compliance with the college’s bylaws, the Corporations Act, Work Health and Safety (WHS) legislation, and principles of natural justice.
  • A correction to an earlier report clarified that Dr Nicholas Buckmaster was never the meeting’s chair; Professor Martin opened the session.

Background of the Conflict
The Royal Australasian College of Physicians (RACP) oversees the training and accreditation of more than 33,000 doctors across 33 specialties in Australia and New Zealand. For several months the college has been gripped by a dispute between its current president, Professor Jennifer Martin, and the president‑elect, Dr Sharmila Chandran. Martin has sought to amend the RACP constitution to separate the roles of president and board chair, mirroring governance structures used by other medical colleges. Chandran and her supporters have opposed this change, arguing that it would diminish the authority of the elected presidency and disrupt continuity of leadership.

The Board Meeting Incident
On Wednesday 22 April 2026, tensions boiled over during a scheduled board meeting held at the college’s O’Connell Street offices. According to a statement issued later that afternoon by the RACP board, initial attempts to appoint honorary treasurer Dr Nicholas Buckmaster as an impartial chair were contested, leaving Professor Martin in the chair. The board alleges that Dr Chandran then “spoke over” Martin and refused to yield the floor, despite Martin’s efforts to maintain order. Chandran is said to have directed the meeting’s livestream to focus the cameras on her before moving the proceedings to a closed room, excluding Martin, the college’s chief executive officer, other directors, and the interim company secretary.

Claims of an Unauthorized Vote
While the meeting was reportedly underway in the closed room, members watching the online feed observed a session chaired by Chandran. At its conclusion, a result was announced indicating that 54.5 % of participants voted in favor of ousting Professor Martin, thereby installing Chandran as chair of the board. The board’s statement emphasized that Martin—despite being physically present nearby—was never given an opportunity to address the members or defend her position. Consequently, the board declared the meeting procedurally flawed and the vote invalid.

Board’s Legal and Governance Concerns
The RACP board expressed “grave concerns” about the constitutionality of the meeting, asserting that it breached the college’s own bylaws, the Corporations Act, Work Health and Safety (WHS) regulations, and fundamental principles of natural justice. The board contended that the vote was not properly scrutineered, that proper notice and quorum requirements were not met, and that the process deprived Martin of the right to be heard. As a result, the board announced it was seeking legal counsel to determine any potential ramifications and to consider actions that might uphold the college’s governance integrity.

Chandran’s Response and Counterclaims
Dr Sharmila Chandran dismissed the board’s statement as “incorrect and completely and utterly inappropriate.” She asserted that the board, as constituted after the vote, now recognized her as its chair, declaring, “The board is me; I am the chair of the board now.” Chandran framed the outcome as a legitimate expression of member will, stating that “the members have spoken.” She further claimed to have already contacted the Australian Charities and Not‑for‑profits Commission (ACNC) to inform them that Professor Martin was no longer the chair of RACP’s board, signaling her intent to institutionalize the leadership change regardless of the board’s objections.

Police Involvement and Findings
Following Chandran’s allegation that she had been intimidated, her husband called police to the O’Connell Street office at approximately 10:30 am on Wednesday. NSW Police confirmed they attended the scene, spoke with several individuals present, and concluded that no criminal offence had been committed. The police report emphasized that while the situation was heated and involved raised voices, there was no evidence of assault, threats, or any breach of criminal law that warranted charges or further investigation.

Correction to Earlier Reporting
An earlier version of the news story incorrectly identified Dr Nicholas Buckmaster as the chair of the Wednesday meeting. A subsequent correction clarified that Professor Jennifer Martin opened the meeting in the chair role, and any attempt to appoint Buckmaster as an impartial chair was disputed and never effected. This amendment underscores the fluid and contested nature of the proceedings, highlighting how competing narratives can quickly shape public perception before facts are verified.

Implications for RACP and Medical Governance
The episode exposes structural vulnerabilities within RACP’s governance model, particularly regarding the transition of power between incumbent and elected leaders. It raises questions about the clarity of constitutional provisions for removing a president, the mechanisms for ensuring impartial chairmanship during contentious meetings, and the safeguards needed to protect the rights of all directors to participate and be heard. Stakeholders across the medical education sector may scrutinize the incident as a case study in how internal disputes can escalate to involve law enforcement and external regulators, potentially jeopardizing the college’s reputation and its ability to fulfill its accreditation mandate.

Conclusion and Outlook
As of the latest updates, the RACP board continues to evaluate the legality of the meeting convened by Dr Chandran, while Chandran maintains her claim to leadership based on the member vote she alleges took place. The involvement of police—though ultimately non‑criminal—signals the seriousness with which the conflict is being regarded. Moving forward, the college will likely need to revisit its bylaws, clarify dispute‑resolution procedures, and perhaps engage external mediators to restore confidence among its members, trainees, and the broader healthcare community. The outcome will not only shape the immediate leadership of RACP but may also influence governance reforms across similar professional bodies in Australasia.

SignUpSignUp form

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here