Key Takeaways:
- The show "All’s Fair," created by Ryan Murphy and starring Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, and Niecy Nash, is critically panned as exceptionally bad television.
- The writing is highlighted as a significant weakness, featuring cringeworthy dialogue and a nonsensical plot.
- The performances, including those of experienced actors, are considered embarrassing, with characters lacking depth and motivation.
- The show’s attempt at portraying female empowerment is deemed outdated and superficial.
- The reviewer strongly discourages viewers from watching the series, emphasizing its overall poor quality.
"All’s Fair," the new series from Ryan Murphy starring Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, and Niecy Nash, has been met with overwhelmingly negative reviews, with one critic describing it as "fascinatingly, incomprehensibly, existentially terrible." The show, which revolves around an all-female law firm serving wealthy women in California, has been criticized for its abysmal writing, embarrassing performances, and outdated concept of female empowerment.
The dialogue is a significant point of contention, with examples such as "Let’s put the ‘team’ in ‘teamwork’" and "My flight was turbulent and so is my mood" cited as evidence of the show’s poor script. The plot is described as equally weak, with the legal cases being resolved too quickly and lacking any real depth or complexity.
The performances are also heavily criticized. Kim Kardashian, playing a football star’s wife, is described as expressionless and inoffensively useless. Naomi Watts is said to preen and pout, resembling a caricature of Ally McBeal at her worst. Even seasoned actors like Sarah Paulson are unable to deliver compelling performances, given the poor quality of the writing and the outlandish scenarios they are forced to enact. Niecy Nash, while faring slightly better due to the comedic nature of her role, still falls victim to stereotypical portrayals of Black women as "Loud! And Sassy!"
Beyond the technical flaws, the show’s attempt at portraying female empowerment is considered outdated and superficial. The characters’ motivations and actions are often driven by material wealth and superficial concerns, undermining any genuine message of female strength or independence. The show’s obsession with brand names and conspicuous consumption further detracts from any attempt at meaningful commentary.
In conclusion, "All’s Fair" is described as a colossal failure that falls far below any acceptable standard of television. The critic strongly discourages viewers from wasting their time on this poorly written, poorly acted, and ultimately pointless series.
